Credit Card Offers Reward the Prudent and the Patient

Over the last few months I received three invitations from American Airlines/ American Express to sign up for a new joint AA-Amex credit card that would not have an annual fee as long as I kept my current American Airlines Citibank MasterCard as well.  As a sign-up bonus, the AA Amex card would give me 20% more miles during the first 12 months.  I assume this offer was sent to all AA Citibank card holders, and although I contemplated signing up for the card, I ultimately decided that 20% was not enough to convince me to add another card to my wallet.

We already wrote about checking your “junk mail” for interesting offers, but here I clarify that statement – don’t jump into any “junk mail” offer you get either.  Weigh the offer and consider your circumstances as well.  Naturally, if you accepted every single credit card invitation that included some kind of reward, you credit score would probably suffer while your wallet would likely be overflowing with cards.  Rather, when deciding whether to switch or take on a new rewards credit card, consider how it fits with your other cards.  Is the new card offering you a 1% cash back on everything when you already have a card that offers that?  Does it make sense for you to take on a new credit card with a different rewards program and split up your point accumulation?  That’ll largely depend on whether each of the reward schemes offers something unique and valuable to you, the reward rate of each card, as well as how much you put on your credit card each month.  If your credit card bill is small and it already takes you a while to accumulate enough points for a reward, for example, splitting your purchases between two cards will mean it’ll take even longer.

On the other hand, if you have a card that has a good reward rate for a limited range of purchase categories, such as the CitiForward card, which offers 5 points per dollar on books, movies, music, and restaurants, having another card that has a bonus on other purchases could work for you.  In this example, if you make a significant amount on your purchases by credit card, you could complement the CitiForward with the American Express Blue Cash card, which gives 5% cash back on purchases at supermarkets, gas stations, and drug stores once you spend $6,500 on it (or a 1% cash back on those purchase categories before you reach the threshold).

As for the AA Amex card, I decided not to get it because the industry standard rates a 1 mile reward to be equivalent to roughly 2 cents.  With a 20% bonus, that would only go up to 2.4 cents.  The difference between getting 2% back and 2.4% cash back isn’t significant enough to change my spending patterns, particularly since I also have the Discover More card, which has 5% cash back offers that change quarterly and the CitiForward card.

Besides, last week I got a very interesting offer in the mail: American Airlines will be giving me a 20% bonus with my current AA Citibank credit card until the end of May 2010.  No new credit card required, only a call to an automated customer service line and inputting the “individualized offer code” that came in the letter.  Yet another example of why it pays to wait and to check your “junk” mail.

One Response

  1. I found your blog post while searching google. Quite impressive too, since google usually shows relatively old results but this one is very recent! Anyway, very informative, especially since this is not something many people are able to write something good about. Take care…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: